The tradition of the European spirit knows no situation of such affecting loftiness, tenderness, fruitfulness. It is the meeting of the two greatest Latins" Curt. There can be no doubt that Virgil plays an essential role in almost every aspect of Dante's composition of his great poem, and probably with his very decision to write an "epic" poem, leaving incomplete his two treatises, Convivio and De vulgari Eloquentia , in order to attach himself firmly to the great Latin tradition of writing about serious things in verse.
As has frequently been pointed out, Virgil's example may be found as seminal for many aspects of Dante's poetic strategies in the Commedia : to write a poem that prominently features a visit to the underworld Dante did not know Homer's texts, if he did know about them -- thus he can behave as though Virgil were uniquely qualified to serve as his model and that celebrates the Roman concept of political order as exemplified in the empire; that is narrated by a poet who has been lent prophetic powers.
As one of the principal characters in Dante's poem Toynbee, in his entry for the Roman poet, offers a convenient listing of all of his appearances [ Virgilio ] , Virgil's presence as guide in this most Christian of poems is something of a scandal. It is at least possible that puzzlement about Dante's reasons for choosing him for this role is at the root of the early commentators' tactic of treating the poem, not as the "history" of an actual experience that Dante claims it to be with a consequent treatment of Virgil as the historical figure he is so clearly meant to be considered , but as an allegorical fiction.
While in fact the introductory information processed in the poem [Inf I ] makes Virgil entirely and recognizably historical Mantuan parents, approximate dating of birth and career, authorship of Aeneid , commentators responded and, sometimes, still respond by making Virgil "Reason" or some related allegorical characteristic of the human psyche. The poem that is created by such interpretation is thus meant to be considered the record of an internal struggle in a threatened Christian soul, as represented by the contending forces of appetite whose role is supposedly played by the character Dante and those of reason personified in Virgil.
While the Aeneid itself was subjected to such readings by interpreters like Fulgentius and the pseudo- [? Dante's treatment of the greatest Latin poet makes his Virgil a problematic character for the earliest interpreters of the Commedia. Yet there are other problems, not of a commentator's devising, that afflict our attempt to come to grips with Dante's choice of Virgil as the guide in his poem.
And these problems arise from Dante's own troubled perception of his pagan poetic hero. One tradition of Christian reception of Virgil, which is at least as old as the emperor Constantine, held that Virgil's much-discussed fourth Eclogue actually foretold the coming of Christ. Had Dante so believed, his choice of Virgil might have been less burdensome. However, we may be certain from Monarchia Mon. We must conclude that Dante willfully chose a pagan as his guide, leaving us to fathom his reasons for doing so.
In recent years a growing number of Dante's interpreters have been arguing for the view that Dante deliberately undercuts his guide, showing that both in some of his decisions as guide and in some of his own actual texts he is, from Dante's later and Christian vantage point, prone to error. If this is the case, we must not forget that Dante at the same time is intent upon glorifying Virgil. And then we might consider the proposition that Dante's love for Virgil, genuine and heartfelt, needed to be held at arm's length and gently chastised, perhaps revealing to a pagan-hating reader that Dante knows full well the limitations of his Virgil.
Yet he could not do without him. Virgil is the guide in Dante's poem because he served in that role in Dante's life. It was Virgil, and not Aristotle or Aquinas, who served as model for the poem; it was Virgil who, more than any other author, helped make Dante Dante. Though a pagan, Virgil lived a virtuous life and is therefore able to guide Dante through Inferno and Purgatorio.
Aside from being represented as a guide and teacher, Virgil is represented as the voice of reason in a world full of sin. Within the Second Circle of Hell, the souls of the Lustful swirl about in the wind, swept helplessly through the stormy air.
Dante immediately feels sympathy for these souls, because they are basically damned by love. One soul named Francesca, tells to Dante how love was her downfall. Written by Dante Alighieri, a great poet of the 14th century banned from his home, Inferno describes the journey of Dante himself as a man who has lost his way in the woods, which represents losing his way from the righteous path.
In order to find salvation, Dante must take a journey through Hell with the guidance of the poet Virgil, who represents human reason. The poem depicts many theological ideas that people of the time may have believed, but enhances their effectiveness through graphic punishments that await sinners in Hell.
Superficially, Vanni Fucci seems to be motivated by thievery. Deeper insight gained from close reading reveals, however, that Vanni Fucci has lost the good of the intellect in the following sense that he is a megalomaniac and believes that he is to be a ruler of Florence. This thesis will be demonstrated by means of principles of close reading, including details, misprision and under-specification.
Inferno Dante - Symbology Within The Poem Alison Wong Dante and Virgil are historical figures who have established themselves as poets, writers and philosophers through their achievement in ancient literature.
Virgil is one of the greatest poets in the Augustan era , who passed away before Christ and the spread of Christianity. Virgil is seen in Inferno as a great poet whom Dante admires greatly. Within the poem, Dante receives much inspiration from Virgil and also constantly displays his respect and admiration for him throughout the whole of the text.
Virgil's great task is to get Dante to harden his heart against the most horribly damned shades in Hell. He succeeds, and he shows Dante how to climb Lucifer's leg and then turn upright to see the stars of Purgatory ahead of him.
Previous Dante. Next Character Map. Once Rhea chose it as the secret crypt and cradle of her son; and better to hide him, her Corybantes raised a din when he wept. Virgil, therefore, contributed towards a better understanding of the journey because he tells Dante about the history behind the events and features that they are witnessing. As such, he is a guide to Dante.
Sometimes Dante was uncertain about the next step. These were all unfamiliar things that were potentially dangerous. Dante needed someone to assure him that he was going in the right direction. The journey would have been extraordinarily scary without Virgil. In fact, it is likely that Dante would have turned back at the entrance to hell if it had not been for Virgil.
My Guide! My Master! Now lead on. Virgil reminded the main character about the importance of his mission and thus propelled him to achieve it. In certain scenarios, Dante even consider Virgil as a father because of the things he did for him.
For instance, when they got to Dis, some furies threatened to turn both Dante and Virgil into stone. Virgil quickly urged Dante to cover his eyes and turn around. When Dante took too much time to respond, Virgil himself turned Dante around and covered his eyes for him. In such an instance, Virgil acted in a similar manner to a father.
He cared about Dante and would not allow harm to come to him. Some contend that the non believers do not merit their place in hell because nobody gave them a choice.
This controversial subject also troubled Dante, and as he travels inside hell, he gets answers to this troubling question.
Through Virgil, Dante learns that Christians must make no apologies for their faith.
0コメント